Cultural Capitol - "[In 'Danny and thr Deep Blue Sea'] Erin Cronican takes a star turn as a woman whose love might be able to save Danny, but isn’t enough to save herself. Her performance of Roberta was the most genuine and touching performance I have seen this year."

Peter Filichia - “The finest performances I saw this month came from Erin Cronican and Brandon Walker... I was so impressed at their naturalness; these kids weren’t acting but had just happened to become the characters, that’s all. I look forward to seeing more at The Seeing Place.”

Theater is Easy - "[In 'Closer'] Erin Cronican brings a greater vulnerability to Anna than I have seen in past performances. Her soft toned delivery and wide eyes show Anna to be a well meaning woman who can’t save herself from the imposing will of men... Cronican’s performance gives Anna enough vulnerability for her to be an entirely sympathetic character."

NY Daily News -- "As the wily reporter, Erin Cronican is enormously winning, excelling in "Once in a Lifetime" and "I Said It and I'm Glad... This is truly musical comedy, a now extinct species, and it is a marvel to me that you can find performers who can still do it."